Allen’s Coin Shop
Allen’s Coin Shop has been open for over 50 years, and since 1997 their store has had full online ordering for coins, currency, stamps and the rest of their inventory. From Barber quarters to modern commemoratives, they have a wide selection of numismatic coins available for purchase.
399 S State St ,Westerville, OH 43081
(614) 882-3937 American Coin & Collectibles
American Coin & Collectibles began in 1978, then changed ownership and name in 1994. It specializes in bullion and coins, but also purchases other Precious Metal pieces including jewelry and pocket watches. They keep American Eagle coins in Gold, Silver and Platinum as well as graded and slabbed collector coins from early cents through St. Gaudens. This dealer often buys collections and estates to replenish their inventory.
3501 E Livingston Ave ,Columbus, OH 43227
(614) 231-1008 Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry
Buckeye Gold Coin & Jewelry buys and sells Gold, Silver, Platinum, coins, gemstones and currency. They usually use the acid test and a resistance test to find how authentic the metals are and what degree of purity they have, then pay cash for anything they wish to purchase. There are eight different locations throughout the Columbus area that they use to buy and sell Precious Metals and coins.
190 Graceland Blvd ,Columbus, OH 43214
(614) 846-4653 Grove City Coins and Currency
Grove City Coin & Currency is a coin shop primarily, but also a buyer of Gold, Silver, Platinum, diamonds, jewelry and currency. Numismatics are a specialty, and they can appraise coins for the value they have above and beyond the value of the metal. Coin collectors can get the services they need here to find the pieces to fill out their collection.
2655 Columbus St ,Grove City, OH 43123
(614) 946-3846 Old Hilliard Coin
John Zappitelli has been a lifetime collector and investor in coins and bullion, and in 2010 he turned his passion into a business by opening Old Hilliard Coin & Fine Art, LLC. Formal appraisals are available here for a fee which will be waived if the collection is sold to this dealer. They keep an online store that stocks bullion and coins from Indian cents to slabbed proof Silver Eagles.
5275 Norwich Street ,Hilliard, OH 43026
(614) 334-2722 Gemco Coins
Gemco Coins began as a dealer in coins, currency, Precious Metals and jewelry. They became a pawnbroker as well in 2012 but the focus of the business is still on bullion and coins. Gemco sells through their storefront and their eBay store. Inventory depends on what has been brought in for sale or pawn.
5311 W. Broad St ,Columbus, OH 43228
(614) 878-2646 Arlington Coin & Watchworks
Arlington Coin & Watchworks is a coin and watch dealer that also deals in currency, bullion, Precious Metals of all types and collectibles. They keep graded numismatic coins on hand from wheat cents to proof sets. This dealer also does auctions.
2094 Tremont Ctr ,Columbus, OH 43221
(614) 488-4290 