Sign In or Create Account

Knowledge Center

How to Sell Junk Silver Coins 

how to sell junk silver coins

The process of buying or selling silver coins varies depending on the type, silver content, and market for the items. If you have a collection of junk silver, you might be wondering how to sell junk silver coins. The term “junk silver” typically refers to pre-1965 U.S. coins that contain silver. Junk silver coins may not hold significant numismatic value but remain a sought-after commodity among investors and collectors for their silver content. Whether you’re new to the world of precious metals or looking to refine your selling strategies, ensuring you’re well-equipped to navigate the sale of your junk silver collection effectively is important. 

Junk Silver Coins 

When exploring how to sell junk silver coins, it is first essential to understand what junk silver is. While the phrase usually references pre-1965 circulated U.S. coins containing 90% silver, there are other types of junk silver coins.  

Examples of junk silver coins include the U.S. Mercury Dimes minted until 1945, the Silver Washington Quarters, and the Franklin and Walking Liberty Half Dollars minted before 1965. These coins are composed of 90% silver and 10% copper, making them highly sought after by investors and collectors who value silver for its investment potential and historical interest. 

Coin Type Silver Content 
Pre-1965 U.S. dimes, quarters, and half dollars 90% 
Kennedy Half Dollars dated 1965-1969 40% 
Jefferson Nickels dated from 1942-1945 with a large P, D, or S above Monticello 35% 
Pre-1968 Canadian dimes, quarters, and half dollars  80% 
Examples of Junk Silver Coins 

Unlike collectible coins valued for their rarity, historical significance, or condition, junk silver coins are valued for their metal content. These coins are an attractive option for investors looking to hold physical silver, as they offer a straightforward way to invest in precious metals without the higher premiums often associated with bullion coins or bars. 

Preparing to Sell Junk Silver Coins 

When you’re preparing to sell your junk silver coins, there are essential steps to follow to ensure you’re fully primed for a profitable transaction. This preparation hinges on understanding your coins’ value and market demand. It’s also essential to separate junk silver coins from any with numismatic value.  

Identify Your Junk Silver Coins 

Identifying junk silver coins from those not junk silver involves understanding the composition and mint years of the coins. Junk silver coins are typically pre-1965 U.S. coins made of 90% silver, including dimes, quarters, and half dollars. These coins were minted before the U.S. Mint shifted and eliminated silver from coinage. To differentiate, look for the year the coin was minted. Examine the coin for mint marks and verify its weight and diameter to help confirm its status as junk silver. This process is essential to accurately assess your holdings’ value and potential investment return. 

Separate Numismatic Coins 

Before selling your collection of junk silver coins, it’s crucial to meticulously sort through them to identify and separate any special editions or coins that might hold numismatic value beyond their silver content. Occasionally, rare coins with historical significance or unique mint errors can be mixed with junk silver coins. These coins could fetch a premium if sold to collectors or numismatic enthusiasts rather than being traded for their melt value. Taking the time to examine your coins carefully can ensure you do not inadvertently sell a valuable piece for its silver content alone, potentially missing out on a more lucrative opportunity. This process maximizes your returns and enhances your understanding and appreciation of your collection’s worth. 

Assess the Value of Your Junk Silver Coins 

The current silver price determines the value of junk silver coins. The next step when learning how to sell junk silver coins involves calculating the melt price of your coins, which represents the base value of the silver content. 

Melt Price = Silver Price/Ounce × Weight of the Coin in Ounces × Silver Purity 

Given that most junk silver coins are made from 90% silver and 10% copper, this calculation will help you understand the minimum value of your coins based on their silver content alone. Junk silver coins can be dimes, quarters, half dollars, and sometimes nickels, so it is important to determine the weight of each before multiplying by their purity. Additionally, some nickels only have 35% purity, while half dollars minted between 1965 and 1969 are only made of 40% silver.  

Melt Price of Junk Silver = Silver Price/Ounce × Weight of Specific Coin × Purity of Specific Coin 

After establishing the intrinsic metal value, the next steps include assessing the condition of your coins and confirming their authenticity. Although junk silver coins are not usually valued for their numismatic qualities, exceptional conditions can add a slight premium above the melt value. 

Market Research 

Understanding the intricacies of the silver market is crucial for anyone interested in selling junk silver coins. Conducting thorough market research is imperative to capitalize on the most opportune moments to maximize your returns from selling junk silver coins. While it is challenging to predict the market, the best way to make the most of junk silver coins is to sell when silver prices are high. Additionally, familiarizing yourself with the various categories of junk silver coins can significantly influence their selling price.  

  • Bulk Junk Silver Coins: Often sold by weight, these coins are valued for their silver content rather than collectibility. 
  • Rare Date or Mintmark Coins: Certain junk silver coins may carry a premium due to their rarity or specific historical significance. 
  • Junk Silver Coin Sets: Selling coins as part of a set or collection can sometimes yield a higher value than selling them individually. 

Each type of junk silver coin can command a different premium. Gaining knowledge and staying informed about market trends will enhance your success in selling junk silver coins. 

Choosing Where to Sell Junk Silver Coins 

Deciding where to sell your junk silver coins is the next step in how to sell junk silver coins. Each option offers its own set of benefits and possible drawbacks. When determining where to sell your junk silver coins, consider the speed of sale, the effort you’re willing to put in, and the financial return you’re aiming for. Your choice should reflect your personal selling goals and expectations. 

Local Coin Shop 

Selling junk silver coins at a coin or pawn shop can provide a swift and straightforward transaction. These establishments often have experienced staff who can evaluate your coins and make an on-the-spot offer. The primary benefits include direct interaction and the chance for a quick sale. However, you might find that the return is less than what you could achieve elsewhere since a pawn shop relies on the resale of such items to stay in business. 

Online Marketplace 

Platforms like eBay or specialized coin auction sites can expose your junk silver coins to a broader audience, potentially leading to better prices. Success in this arena relies on showcasing your coins with clear photographs and comprehensive descriptions. Keep in mind that fees and shipping costs can affect your net proceeds. 

Investors or Silver Stackers 

Selling directly to silver stackers or investors might be a great way to profit from junk silver coins, depending on the price you paid for them. Investors, silver stackers, and silver accumulators buy large amounts of junk silver based on the prediction that silver prices will increase in future markets. Engaging with coin investing and silver stacking communities is an effective way to connect with interested buyers.  

Sell to Reputable Dealers 

Turning to reputable dealers that specialize in silver, like APMEX, for selling your junk silver coins is another practical choice. Such dealers generally provide a seamless selling experience, offering online quotes and straightforward shipping instructions. Opting for a trusted dealer can streamline the selling process, ensuring a safe and hassle-free way to convert your junk silver coins into cash. 

Guide for How to Sell Junk Silver Coins 

Selling junk silver coins necessitates understanding the market and potential buyers’ diverse interests. You’re mainly going to only achieve selling for the melt value of the coins, so the platform should be chosen based on your individual goals. The following provides a comprehensive approach for selling junk silver coins, whether to local coin shops, online platforms, collectors or investors, or reputable dealers like APMEX. 

Guide for Selling to a Local Coin Shop 

  1. Research Local Shops: Seek out well-regarded coin shops in your vicinity, prioritizing those with positive feedback and a solid reputation in the community. 
  1. Prepare and Present Your Coins: Organize your junk silver coins, focusing on the overall silver content of your collection. Show them in a manner that emphasizes their silver content and potential value. 
  1. Negotiate the Price: Equip yourself with knowledge about the silver market and the specific value of your coins to negotiate effectively. 
  1. Complete the Sale: Finalize the transaction to receive payment, making sure to get a receipt for the sale. 

Guide for Selling Online 

  1. Choose a Platform: Opt for an online marketplace or auction site that caters to coin collectors or silver stackers, particularly those interested in junk silver coins. 
  1. Create an Attractive Listing: Register and list your junk silver coins, employing high-quality photos and detailed descriptions to attract buyers. Be transparent about their condition and highlight unique qualities. 
  1. Communicate with Potential Buyers: Reply promptly to any queries, as effective communication can lead to more favorable offers. 
  1. Arrange Payment and Shipping: Secure payment before dispatching the coins via an insured and traceable shipping method. 
  1. Keep Accurate Records: Keep detailed transaction records for your records and tax purposes. 

Guide for Selling to Collectors or Investors 

  1. Network with Silver Buyers: Engage with communities dedicated to buying silver online and in person. Attend coin shows and conventions or participate in forums to encounter prospective buyers. 
  1. Present Your Coins: Showcase your junk silver coins attractively, focusing on their silver content, rarity, and historical significance. 
  1. Negotiate: Negotiate with interested buyers, using your knowledge of the current silver market to secure the best price. 
  1. Complete the Deal: Finalize the sale with a secure payment method and complete all necessary paperwork. 

Guide for Selling to APMEX 

  1. Contact Us: Contact APMEX with details about your junk silver coins, including their weight, condition, and quantity. 
  1. Get a Price Quote: Our experts will provide a quote based on the prevailing silver market conditions and the specifics of your collection. 
  1. Ship the Coins: Safely package your coins for shipping, ensuring they’re well-protected during transit. 
  1. Professional Verification: Upon arrival, our specialists will verify the authenticity and condition of your coins. 
  1. Complete the Deal: After the verification process, the sale will be finalized, and you’ll receive payment along with official documentation. 

Selling junk silver coins involves similar steps to selling other precious metals but requires an understanding of the specific market for silver. By following this guide, you can navigate the selling process efficiently and achieve the best outcome for your collection of junk silver coins. 

Paying Taxes After Selling Junk Silver Coins 

Understanding the tax implications of selling junk silver coins is critical for ensuring a hassle-free transaction and avoiding potential legal complications. Sellers must be aware of the capital gains tax that applies to the profit earned from the sale of these coins, as well as any pertinent state taxes

It’s essential to accurately calculate these taxes to comply with tax laws and regulations. Furthermore, fulfilling the reporting obligations the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) set forth is mandatory. Failure to report income from the sale of junk silver coins could result in fines and legal challenges. 

We highly recommend consulting a tax professional to navigate the intricate tax landscape. A tax expert can provide detailed insights into the tax duties of selling junk silver coins, ensuring that sellers adhere to all applicable laws. 

Maximizing Returns and Ensuring a Positive Experience 

Selling junk silver coins isn’t just about making a profit; it’s also about ensuring a smooth and enjoyable selling experience. Here are some tips specifically tailored to the unique aspects of junk silver coins to help you maximize your returns and enjoy the process. 

  • Stay Educated: Continuously expand your knowledge about the silver market and trends among collectors of junk silver. Being informed enables you to make strategic decisions and spot profitable opportunities, significantly since junk silver coins can fluctuate in value differently from pure bullion coins. 
  • Market Timing: While predicting market movements with precision is challenging, selling your junk silver coins when silver prices are high can significantly enhance your returns. Since junk silver coins are valued for their metal content, keeping an eye on silver market trends is crucial. 
  • Coin Maintenance: Proper storage and handling are crucial to preserving the condition of your junk silver coins. Even though they are not valued for numismatic purposes, coins in better condition may still command a slight premium. 
  • Cultivate Relationships: Build connections with buyers, especially if you plan to sell regularly. Trust is vital in the niche market of junk silver, where buyers and sellers often rely on repeat dealings and referrals. 
  • Consult Experts: If you need clarification on the value of your junk silver coins or the best time to sell them, consider consulting with professionals or financial advisors who specialize in precious metals and understand the nuances of the silver market. 
  • Confirm Buyer Authenticity: Deal with reputable buyers to minimize the risk of fraud. This is especially pertinent when selling junk silver, as the market can attract a wide range of buyers. Use trusted coin shops or secure online platforms for transactions. 

Following these strategies can enhance your experience and profitability when selling junk silver coins, making the process rewarding and enjoyable. 

Explore More On APMEX



Rare Coins