Sign In or Create Account

Knowledge Center

How to Sell Silver Buffalos 

sell silver buffalos

Silver Buffalo rounds are a prevalent silver investment and a great alternative to the American Silver Eagle. Investors and collectors purchase Silver Buffalos for their beautiful design and silver purity. Due to their popularity, they are one of the most liquid silver bullion rounds. Knowing how to sell Silver Buffalos can help you make money from your silver stack. This guide provides essential insights into the steps and strategies for selling Silver Buffalos effectively and profitably. 

American Silver Buffalo  

Silver Buffalo rounds feature James Earle Fraser’s design created for the classic Buffalo nickel. It displays an American bison on one side and a Native American profile on the other. James Earle Fraser made the profile by combining the features of three different Native American chiefs. The design of the bison is a representation of Black Diamond, a buffalo that lived in the Central Park Zoo during the early 1900s.  

Silver Buffalo Round 
Location Minted Multiple Private Mints, including 9Fine Mint 
Metal Content .999 fine silver 
Obverse Design Profile of Native American by James Earle Fraser 
Reverse Design Black Diamond Bison by James Earle Fraser 
Weight 1 troy ounce 
Diameter 39.04 mm 
Thickness 2.9 mm 
Special Editions Fractional, 5 oz Silver Buffalo 
Specifications of Silver Buffalos 

The American Silver Buffalos differ from the American Gold Buffalos in multiple ways. Firstly, they do not hold a legal tender status and are not produced by the U.S. Mint. They don’t have a date inscribed on their face and are made by private mints throughout the country. Therefore, Silver Buffalos are not coins but silver bullion rounds. Their value is derived from their silver content.  

While you won’t find certified or graded Silver Buffalos, they are available in fractional sizes. This characteristic is one feature looked at when comparing Silver Eagles coin with Silver Buffalos 

Preparation for Selling Silver Buffalo Rounds 

When planning to sell Silver Buffalos, it’s essential to take several key steps to ensure a smooth and successful sale. Adequate preparation involves understanding the value of your silver and its position in the market. Accurately presenting your assets to potential buyers can make a significant difference in the outcome of your transaction. 

Evaluating Melt Value 

The worth of Silver Buffalos can vary based on several factors but mainly depends on the prevailing silver price. To determine the fundamental value, start with the melt price of your Silver Buffalo. The melt price is the basic worth of the metal content if you melt the round. 

Melt Price = Metal Price/Ounce x Weight of the Round in Ounces x Metal Purity 

For the 1 oz Silver Buffalo, this is equivalent to the current spot price of silver. However, the Silver Buffalos are made in fractional sizes and even a 5 oz variety, so you must do the appropriate math to get the exact melt value. 

Silver Buffalo Melt Price = Silver Price/Ounce x Weight in Troy Ounces x Purity (.999 or similar) 

Once you have an idea of the intrinsic metal value, you can proceed to assess the Silver Buffalo’s condition and authenticity. 

Condition and Authenticity 

The selling price of your Silver Buffalo is influenced by more than just the silver content. The condition plays a vital role in determining potential profits. Start by examining the physical state of your Silver Buffalo, looking for any signs of wear, scratches, or other marks that could diminish its value. Items in excellent condition usually command higher prices. 

You’ll also want to ensure authenticity before you sell Silver Buffalos. Verifying that your silver is genuine and not a counterfeit is essential. You can authenticate your silver through home tests or professional verification. Selling a counterfeit can severely damage your reputation in the numismatic community.  

Market Research for Silver Buffalos 

Staying updated on current silver prices and understanding their impact on your Silver Buffalos’ value is crucial. Investigate recent sales of comparable items to gauge what buyers are willing to pay. Stay current on the basics of silver investing and what affects the silver market. Timing your sale with higher silver prices can give you an excellent investment return. Additionally, a buyer will usually expect a discount on buying more silver rounds, such as a tube of 20 Silver Buffalos. Keep this in mind if you are selling more significant amounts, such as tubes or boxes of Silver Buffalo rounds.  

Different Types of Silver Buffalos 

Silver Buffalo rounds are most common as a 1 troy ounce .999 fine silver bullion round. However, they are available in fractional sizes, such as 1/10 oz, ¼ oz, and ½ oz. Additionally, 5 oz Silver Buffalos are on the market, which allows you to invest in a more significant amount of silver while getting the same beautifully designed silver piece.  

Importance of Documentation  

Proper documentation is a vital aspect of the selling process. The presence of original packaging or certificates of authenticity can enhance the appeal and value of your silver items to potential buyers. 

Maintaining the original packaging demonstrates authenticity and suggests meticulous care. Also, keeping sets of 20 or more in their tubes can help preserve their condition.   

Presenting documents when selling your Silver Buffalos not only ensures a transparent transaction but also significantly increases the trust and interest of potential buyers, leading to a more efficient sale. Documentation is also vital for reporting gains on your tax return. 

Selecting Where to Sell Silver Buffalos  

Making an informed decision about the best place and strategy to sell Silver Buffalos is vital to ensure a successful experience. Each option presents its own set of advantages and considerations. Your choice should be influenced by your specific objectives and the resources you have at your disposal. 

Local Coin Shop 

Selling your Silver Buffalo rounds at nearby coin shops or pawnshops is a straightforward and rapid option. This route is suitable for those seeking immediate transactions. However, these establishments often propose lower prices to cover their profit margins. It’s wise to shop around and compare offers from multiple stores before deciding. 

Online Marketplaces 

Online platforms like eBay can expose your Silver Buffalos to a broader audience, potentially leading to better offers. Drawbacks include the fees associated with these platforms and the potential for fraudulent activity. It’s essential to provide thorough descriptions and high-quality images to attract genuine buyers. 

Direct Sales to Collectors or Investors 

Engaging in direct transactions with collectors or investors can be the most lucrative approach, as it eliminates intermediaries. This method requires you to build connections within the numismatic community. Coin exhibitions and online forums dedicated to coin collectors are excellent places to foster these relationships. 

Esteemed Dealers 

Opting to sell Silver Buffalos to a trusted dealer like APMEX® streamlines and secures the selling process. This approach simplifies the transaction by providing online expert evaluations and convenient shipping options. Choosing APMEX® means you bypass the hassle of negotiation, handling inquiries from buyers, and the risk of scams, offering a hassle-free way to sell your Silver Buffalo rounds. 

Procedure for Selling Silver Buffalo Rounds 

Guide to Selling at a Local Coin Store 

  1. Find a Trusted Coin Store: Research to locate coin stores experienced in buying American Silver Buffalo rounds. Seek out stores with good reviews and a good reputation in the community.  
  1. Set Up a Meeting: Contact your selected stores to arrange a visit. Be prepared to present your Silver Buffalos, ideally accompanied by any pertinent documents or unique features. 
  1. Negotiate the Price: Be ready to negotiate the value of your collection based on any special features and the total melt price of your items.  
  1. Finalize the Deal: Once you agree on a price, complete the sale with the necessary documentation and hand over the Silver Buffalos. Ensure you record the sale for tax purposes, noting any profits or losses. 

Guide to Selling Online 

  1. Select a Suitable Platform: Choose an online marketplace that collectors and investors frequent. eBay is a good choice for auctioning or direct sales, particularly for distinct variations of American Silver Buffalos. 
  1. Create an Effective Listing: Sign up on your chosen platform and prepare a detailed listing. Provide high-resolution photos and comprehensive descriptions highlighting your Silver Buffalo rounds’ particular features and condition. 
  1. Handle Queries and Offers: Respond to questions and offers from potential buyers promptly and professionally, maintaining clear communication throughout. 
  1. Conclude the Sale: Complete the sale once you accept an offer or at the end of an auction. Opt for secure, insured shipping methods and keep precise transaction records. 

Guide to Selling to Collectors or Investors 

  1. Network and Engage: Participate in the coin collector community by attending coin shows, joining online forums, and becoming a member of local collector clubs. Building relationships in the community is advantageous for selling extensive collections of Silver Buffalo rounds. 
  1. Present Your Silver Buffalos: Highlight the unique features of your items to potential buyers, such as their condition, varieties, or mint marks if they contain them.  
  1. Complete the Transaction: Negotiate a fair price, receive payment, and transfer the silver securely and efficiently. Ensure all necessary documentation is completed for a transparent and lawful transaction. 

Guide to Selling to APMEX® 

  1. Initiate the Process: Send detailed information about your Silver Buffalos to APMEX®, including the size, condition, and quantity. 
  1. Receive a Quote: APMEX® will offer a quote based on the current market value and the specifics of your collection. 
  1. Prepare for Shipping: Pack your Silver Buffalos securely for shipping to APMEX®, ensuring they are well-protected to maintain their condition. 
  1. Verification by Experts: APMEX®’s team will meticulously check the authenticity and condition of your Silver Buffalos upon arrival. 
  1. Finalize the Transaction: Following verification, APMEX® will finalize the sale, and you will receive payment along with documentation detailing the sale. 

Tax Implications When You Sell Silver Buffalos 

Understanding the tax consequences is crucial when you sell precious metals at a profit. The revenue generated from these sales may be subject to capital gains tax, depending on your holding period and the profit earned. On the other hand, any losses can be claimed to offset other gains.  

Grasping Capital Gains Tax 

  • Duration-Based Taxation: Profits from precious metals sold within a year of purchase are treated as short-term capital gains and taxed like regular income. Conversely, metal held for over a year falls under long-term capital gains tax. 
  • Calculating Your Profit: Your capital gain is the difference between the silver’s selling price and purchase cost, including any related acquisition expenses. 
  • Reporting to the IRS: Reporting these gains on your tax filings is mandatory. Capital losses can offset other capital gains, so accurate record-keeping of all transactions, including purchase and sale dates, prices, and expenses, is crucial. 

Professional Tax Guidance 

Due to the intricacies of tax regulations, consulting with a tax expert is advisable, particularly for substantial or frequent transactions. They can advise on your situation and help ensure you adhere to tax laws. Selling precious metals like silver can be profitable, but knowing tax obligations is critical to avoiding surprises during tax season. 

Maximizing Returns and Enhancing the Selling Experience 

Achieving success in selling Silver Buffalos involves more than just profit; it’s about ensuring a smooth and pleasant transaction. Here are some strategies to help enhance your returns and enjoy the process. 

  • Stay Knowledgeable: Continuously learn about the silver market and collector trends. Informed decision-making and identifying good opportunities require market awareness. 
  • Market Timing: Selling when silver prices are high, though challenging to predict, can significantly boost your profit. 
  • Storage and Care: Store and handle your rounds properly to maintain their condition, as well-preserved silver often fetches higher prices. 
  • Relationship Building: Cultivate relationships with buyers, especially for future sales. Regular dealings with trusted collectors or investors can be beneficial. 
  • Expert Consultations: For insights on your items’ value or the optimal selling time, seek advice from specialists or financial advisors. 
  • Confirm Buyer Authenticity: Ensure you’re dealing with legitimate buyers. Use reputable stores or online platforms to avoid scams. 

By adopting these tactics, you can make selling your Silver Buffalos profitable and a positive and enriching experience. 

Explore More On APMEX



Rare Coins